Chatbox
    You don't have permission to chat.
    Load More
Ocelotl

Overthinking Star Fox

28 posts in this topic

Ocelotl    0
Ocelotl

Hey there, new to this forum, let me know if this has already been a topic.

Since we're headed to another retelling of the Lylat Wars story from SF1 and 64/3D I was interested in doing some overthinking on that story.  What the context is and what the implications for the story are. Are monkeys hated through the galaxy? Did no one really know what Andross was doing on Corneria? Is Andross tapping into some well deserved anger towards Cornerian society? What about those lizards? How did he get them to fight people they've never really knew about? How good is Corneria anyways? Star Fox is a mercenary group, not freedom fighters or military personnel. I wonder if Peppy gets a stipend.

While the game is rather cartoony, you do play as anthropomorphic animals, how do you feel about gunning down other people, anthropomorphic monkeys, who yell out in agony as you gun them down? Should Star Fox even attempt these kinds of stories? I wonder if we can ever truly take it that seriously as a story since they are silly animals. Is this why it's so hard to market Star Fox? While Nintendo hasn't shied away from having violent games on their consoles in recent years, I'm not sure if they're especially comfortable with their characters being so. After all when they tried being a shooter they switched from Andross, living enemies, to emotionless robots... *who were looking for souls?*

An example comes to mind, in 64 when you kill that "My Emperor I've Failed you" guy, it felt pretty rough to me. This guy dies lamenting his failure to his emperor and duty as his machine explodes in a fiery blaze! Not quite as acceptable as killing an aparoid, eh? Luckily you never see any bodies but still...

Anyways, what do y'all think? I know it's silly but let's indulge, no? *Unless y'all alredy did this... oh well*

*I'm sure Lylat Legacy will get to these things but y'know it'll be a while*

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco

Let's not forget the entirety of Assault. And the enemies on Corneria. Actually, the entire Corneria mission. Oh, and how two thousand people just straight up die on Katina during the second mission. And the shield breaking cutscene on the homeworld. Assault is a game that threw out being kid friendly in favor of firmly grasping your feels, squeezing them hard enough to make you deeply uncomfortable, and then tearing them apart and leaving you to pick up the pieces. Why?

Because good ol' Shiggy M is a seriously cruel person. That's why.

By the way, you do see bodies in Assault. In fact, you produce quite a few corpses. Also, spoiler alert, you get to have tons of fun on Sauria walking amongst Aparoid infected, rotting, dinosaur corpses. All this while Krystal worries about the EarthWalkers.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ocelotl    0
Ocelotl
1 minute ago, That Ain't Falco said:

Let's not forget the entirety of Assault. And the enemies on Corneria. Actually, the entire Corneria mission. Oh, and how two thousand people just straight up die on Katina during the second mission. And the shield breaking cutscene on the homeworld. Assault is a game that threw out being kid friendly in favor of firmly grasping your feels, squeezing them hard enough to make you deeply uncomfortable, and then tearing them apart and leaving you to pick up the pieces. Why?

Because good ol' Shiggy M is a seriously cruel person. That's why.

By the way, you do see bodies in Assault. In fact, you produce quite a few corpses. Also, spoiler alert, you get to have tons of fun on Sauria walking amongst Aparoid infected, rotting, dinosaur corpses. All this while Krystal worries about the EarthWalkers.

I wanna agree but Assault felt like it always went halfway with everything. Sure Star Fox got a little more mature and darker but it always took a step back. The Aparoid threat was the first touch. Shooting robots is always acceptable, look at children's animation, however imagine the same game but if you were shooting down Andross' soldiers and mercenaries? Very different feel. Those monkeys have families! *Even a Storm Trooper had a life before service* Hell when the crew assaults *C WUT I DID THER* the Wolfen base you fight these generic bots. Hmmm I don't beleive SF Zero will have ground missions but if they do will they have the same cop-out?

Really? it's been a while since I've visited SF Assault but if I remember correctly  weren't the dinos just infected? the conceit of the game had them healed up by the end didn't it? As rough as it sounds I would've preferred Pigma, Andrew, General Pepper,and Peppy remain dead *SPOILER ALERT!* It cheapens the story to have them almost die and then be just fine, TWICE for Peppy, there be no stakes. Look I don't want every game to be that bleak but if they were gonna go there, go there. Kids can handle it, in fact they have; Macross did it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco
1 minute ago, Ocelotl said:

I wanna agree but Assault felt like it always went halfway with everything. Sure Star Fox got a little more mature and darker but it always took a step back. The Aparoid threat was the first touch. Shooting robots is always acceptable, look at children's animation, however imagine the same game but if you were shooting down Andross' soldiers and mercenaries? Very different feel. Those monkeys have families! *Even a Storm Trooper had a life before service* Hell when the crew assaults *C WUT I DID THER* the Wolfen base you fight these generic bots. Hmmm I don't beleive SF Zero will have ground missions but if they do will they have the same cop-out?

Really? it's been a while since I've visited SF Assault but if I remember correctly  weren't the dinos just infected? the conceit of the game had them healed up by the end didn't it? As rough as it sounds I would've preferred Pigma, Andrew, General Pepper,and Peppy remain dead *SPOILER ALERT!* It cheapens the story to have them almost die and then be just fine, TWICE for Peppy, there be no stakes. Look I don't want every game to be that bleak but if they were gonna go there, go there. Kids can handle it, in fact they have; Macross did it!

You don't fight robots in Sargasso. Those are all pirate ruffians. Also, Andrew and Pigma were brought back in Command, not Assault. Even so, Assault is rated T. It strongly drives in mature themes, and the plot goes incredibly deep, if you look for it. As an example, the game takes a brief detour to mention how Fox has been keeping Krystal off of the ground. He quickly apologizes, and the issue is resolved. Then you wonder why something like that would have happened.

Oh, I don't know, maybe he would be overly protective of a female character because his mother died while he was rather young. He would have been devastated. He would have seen his father devastated. Besides, Krystal has already lost everything. Her home, her people, her family. More reasons for overprotectiveness.

Then you have Panther, and his brilliantly feline character. And Leon's personality, and how it seems to be linked into his backstory. He seems to be an assassin who absolutely lost it somewhere along the line. Then you have Wolf's motivations, which Command just shredded because ???

If there's any game in the series that refuses to go all the way, it would be Command, and where it does go all the way, it does it in the completely wrong ways. Command is a game where Wolf starts an argument, and then gets angry at Fox because he doesn't like arguing. It's a game where Pigma drops a massive innuendo because Q-Games really couldn't be bothered to read the dialogue they wrote. It's a game where both of Falco's themes better suit skiing than flying. It's a game where two pointless female characters get introduced because Q-Games decided everyone needed a family for no reason. This would be okay, if Lucy and Amanda's personalities hadn't consisted of "I'm a GIRL" and little more. Also, family is clearly an important theme in the series. We would have known if Peppy had a wife, let alone a daughter.

Command is a game where everyone winds up with kids. It ends off a series that wasn't ready to end. Now THAT is how you only go half way. Speaking of, the entire Anglar backstory is so half baked it isn't even funny. Really? Radiation? Is that the best they could do?

Sadly, it really does seem so... At least the gameplay was solid.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ArwingFan    112
ArwingFan

Commands story was a total trainwreck; I can see why its not considered canon. For one there are multiple endings with no indication on a canon one and two, it so contradictory. Sure, Adventures and Assaults story were somewhat sloppy but still nowhere near as bad as Commands.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco
Just now, ArwingFan said:

Commands story was a total trainwreck, I can see why its not considered canon. For one there are multiple endings with no indication on a canon one and two, it so contradictory. Sure, Adventures and Assaults story were somewhat sloppy but still nowhere near as bad as Commands.

Adventures didn't take itself seriously at all. Good game, bad Star Fox game. Assault was a game that I only found to be sloppy in the controls department, but it's definitely my favorite in the series.

Personally, I really don't consider Command canon, not even the 'true' ending. Quite frankly, it would have done much better as a spinoff featuring Bill or somebody.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ArwingFan    112
ArwingFan
4 minutes ago, That Ain't Falco said:

Personally, I really don't consider Command canon, not even the 'true' ending. Quite frankly, it would have done much better as a spinoff featuring Bill or somebody.

Which one is the true ending?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco
Just now, ArwingFan said:

Which one is the true ending?

Some people claim the "Fox and Krystal" ending is. I'd rather forget that that ending existed,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ocelotl    0
Ocelotl
30 minutes ago, That Ain't Falco said:

You don't fight robots in Sargasso. Those are all pirate ruffians. Also, Andrew and Pigma were brought back in Command, not Assault. Even so, Assault is rated T. It strongly drives in mature themes, and the plot goes incredibly deep, if you look for it. As an example, the game takes a brief detour to mention how Fox has been keeping Krystal off of the ground. He quickly apologizes, and the issue is resolved. Then you wonder why something like that would have happened.

Oh, I don't know, maybe he would be overly protective of a female character because his mother died while he was rather young. He would have been devastated. He would have seen his father devastated. Besides, Krystal has already lost everything. Her home, her people, her family. More reasons for overprotectiveness.

Then you have Panther, and his brilliantly feline character. And Leon's personality, and how it seems to be linked into his backstory. He seems to be an assassin who absolutely lost it somewhere along the line. Then you have Wolf's motivations, which Command just shredded because ???

If there's any game in the series that refuses to go all the way, it would be Command, and where it does go all the way, it does it in the completely wrong ways. Command is a game where Wolf starts an argument, and then gets angry at Fox because he doesn't like arguing. It's a game where Pigma drops a massive innuendo because Q-Games really couldn't be bothered to read the dialogue they wrote. It's a game where both of Falco's themes better suit skiing than flying. It's a game where two pointless female characters get introduced because Q-Games decided everyone needed a family for no reason. This would be okay, if Lucy and Amanda's personalities hadn't consisted of "I'm a GIRL" and little more. Also, family is clearly an important theme in the series. We would have known if Peppy had a wife, let alone a daughter.

Command is a game where everyone winds up with kids. It ends off a series that wasn't ready to end. Now THAT is how you only go half way. Speaking of, the entire Anglar backstory is so half baked it isn't even funny. Really? Radiation? Is that the best they could do?

Sadly, it really does seem so... At least the gameplay was solid.

Really? I guess I mostly remember their barrel tossing robots... you sure? As much as I liked the expanded lore in Assault it wasn't very deep. Sorry it really wasn't. It had its moments but it never went anywhere with it. The Aparoids were never really a narrative force, why fight them? I get it to save the world but there was a disconnect. At least Andross' forces had character. As for Krystal she was just another poor victim of how women are written in media. her only defining feature here is that she wants to do Fox... and she's a telepath? That never really comes into play. I wish we could've gotten some dialogue about her home planet, I never felt that she was ever really part of Sauria... (Really what I want is a Wing Commander style game with Star Fox, that's just me) (Also we all know the problem with Adventure, the question now is do they keep it or retcon it?)

Hey quick question. Why do so many fans dislike Panther? He seemed fine to be, he was like a feline latin lover. He doesn't really do anything annoying, at least to me. (If anything the way Fox is written in Command it's probably healthier for Krystal to go with Panther who does care for her rather than this dismissive character they wrote for Command)

yeah Command got a little.... crazy with its endings but even before the story was just badly done. Again Krystal's only defining feature is that she's Fox's lady... and little else. Thankfully FOx got chewed out for his stupid sexist decision but in the end her ultimate destiny is tied to Fox and Fox only. All of her decisions are based around him and not her desires. Hell the writers actively punish her for her decisions! That stupid Kursed ending being one of them.

The problem with Command isn't that it ended with kids and a Xerox Generation but that characters got derailed and were not consistent. Then were was the odd female domestication angle, women revert back to their domestic roles after combat? Odd. As for the Anglars... again it has the same problem that all SF games have, that you are fighting other sentient beings rather than aparoids. Hmmm do you feel bad for taking out the Anglars? And should we? Should games that have us kill make us, at least a little bit, uncomfortable? 

19 minutes ago, ArwingFan said:

Commands story was a total trainwreck; I can see why its not considered canon. For one there are multiple endings with no indication on a canon one and two, it so contradictory. Sure, Adventures and Assaults story were somewhat sloppy but still nowhere near as bad as Commands.

Yeah kinda but it was fine for me until the endings. I thought the reason for the multiple endings was because it was probably going to be the last Star Fox? Hmm controls....

16 minutes ago, That Ain't Falco said:

Adventures didn't take itself seriously at all. Good game, bad Star Fox game. Assault was a game that I only found to be sloppy in the controls department, but it's definitely my favorite in the series.

Personally, I really don't consider Command canon, not even the 'true' ending. Quite frankly, it would have done much better as a spinoff featuring Bill or somebody.

Adventure took itself as seriously as it probably should have for the type of adventure it was supposed to be... *hate to beat this dead horse but if it remained Dinosaur Planet it could've gone other places, have some pathos whatever. It's an old argument at this point* I dunno they always seem kinda hesitant to give Star Fox Stronger stories, this ip could easily be Nintendo's Star Wars (Alongside Metroid). 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco
11 minutes ago, Ocelotl said:

Really? I guess I mostly remember their barrel tossing robots... you sure? As much as I liked the expanded lore in Assault it wasn't very deep. Sorry it really wasn't. It had its moments but it never went anywhere with it. The Aparoids were never really a narrative force, why fight them? I get it to save the world but there was a disconnect. At least Andross' forces had character. As for Krystal she was just another poor victim of how women are written in media. her only defining feature here is that she wants to do Fox... and she's a telepath? That never really comes into play. I wish we could've gotten some dialogue about her home planet, I never felt that she was ever really part of Sauria... (Really what I want is a Wing Commander style game with Star Fox, that's just me) (Also we all know the problem with Adventure, the question now is do they keep it or retcon it?)

Hey quick question. Why do so many fans dislike Panther? He seemed fine to be, he was like a feline latin lover. He doesn't really do anything annoying, at least to me. (If anything the way Fox is written in Command it's probably healthier for Krystal to go with Panther who does care for her rather than this dismissive character they wrote for Command)

yeah Command got a little.... crazy with its endings but even before the story was just badly done. Again Krystal's only defining feature is that she's Fox's lady... and little else. Thankfully FOx got chewed out for his stupid sexist decision but in the end her ultimate destiny is tied to Fox and Fox only. All of her decisions are based around him and not her desires. Hell the writers actively punish her for her decisions! That stupid Kursed ending being one of them.

The problem with Command isn't that it ended with kids and a Xerox Generation but that characters got derailed and were not consistent. Then were was the odd female domestication angle, women revert back to their domestic roles after combat? Odd. As for the Anglars... again it has the same problem that all SF games have, that you are fighting other sentient beings rather than aparoids. Hmmm do you feel bad for taking out the Anglars? And should we? Should games that have us kill make us, at least a little bit, uncomfortable? 

Yeah kinda but it was fine for me until the endings. I thought the reason for the multiple endings was because it was probably going to be the last Star Fox? Hmm controls....

Adventure took itself as seriously as it probably should have for the type of adventure it was supposed to be... *hate to beat this dead horse but if it remained Dinosaur Planet it could've gone other places, have some pathos whatever. It's an old argument at this point* I dunno they always seem kinda hesitant to give Star Fox Stronger stories, this ip could easily be Nintendo's Star Wars (Alongside Metroid). 

The franchise already has an incredibly strong story. Next time you play through Assault, don't skip the dialogue or cutscenes. Think about the character interactions, and the implications of the events that take place. If anything, in comparison, Metroid has a shallow plot. Also, the way Assault uses music is absolutely brilliant, especially with the incredibly dissonant Corneria remix. I don't know where you were and why you don't think that the Aparoids aren't a driving narrative force, but they drive so much it isn't even funny. While no, they don't have a ton of exposition, do you really want to know the every in and out of a bunch of space bugs? It's how they affect character motives that they truly influence the plot.

I would go so far as to say that some Star Fox games actually have deeper plots than some Star Wars movies. I mean, gee, A New Hope sure was loaded to the absolute brim with plot and action, right? (Sarcasm, sarcasm, it actually introduces a ton of things it doesn't expand on, and would be considered little more than a cult classic if something similar were released today. It's a copy and pasted hero's journey with little innovation. Artoo and C3PO have more character development than some major characters. These are not good things. Assault, on the other hand, has a deep plot that takes several playthroughs to completely pick up. Characters are deep, and evolve as the plot moves on. It has an overarching theme that honor comes above all, and that sacrifice is often necessary, just as 64 emphasized (quite subtly, but brilliantly) overcoming fears, and Adventures took time to focus on the value of humility and appreciation of others' skills. Even if they are irritating and mostly useless and prone to getting captured.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ocelotl    0
Ocelotl
4 minutes ago, That Ain't Falco said:

The franchise already has an incredibly strong story. Next time you play through Assault, don't skip the dialogue or cutscenes. Think about the character interactions, and the implications of the events that take place. If anything, in comparison, Metroid has a shallow plot. Also, the way Assault uses music is absolutely brilliant, especially with the incredibly dissonant Corneria remix. I don't know where you were and why you don't think that the Aparoids aren't a driving narrative force, but they drive so much it isn't even funny. While no, they don't have a ton of exposition, do you really want to know the every in and out of a bunch of space bugs? It's how they affect character motives that they truly influence the plot.

I would go so far as to say that some Star Fox games actually have deeper plots than some Star Wars movies. I mean, gee, A New Hope sure was loaded to the absolute brim with plot and action, right? (Sarcasm, sarcasm, it actually introduces a ton of things it doesn't expand on, and would be considered little more than a cult classic if something similar were released today. It's a copy and pasted hero's journey with little innovation. Artoo and C3PO have more character development than some major characters. These are not good things. Assault, on the other hand, has a deep plot that takes several playthroughs to completely pick up. Characters are deep, and evolve as the plot moves on. It has an overarching theme that honor comes above all, and that sacrifice is often necessary, just as 64 emphasized (quite subtly, but brilliantly) overcoming fears, and Adventures took time to focus on the value of humility and appreciation of others' skills. Even if they are irritating and mostly useless and prone to getting captured.

Lol. Sure there are moments, like I said, but it's not a particularly complex plot. We can agree to disagree. I ain't sayin' it's bad tho. Now it does have an excellent score. I'll agree to that. Let's look to Star Trek, the Borg are a relatively similar menace, the aparoids never take over anyone like they do (a missed opportunity, Pigma is kind of assimilated but Pepper isn't really) but the conflict from those narratives don't come from the fighting but from the internal conflicts. How would we have them in SF? I don't need the Aparoids to be shakespearean but the situations around them. I kinda wish they were a result of Andross' experiments or meddling that could've forced Andrew's forces to be allies and not give the impression that a single, or two, races are evil. Yeah I know about Dash but he almost always ends up as monkey Hitler.

Well on Star Wars; keep in mind that that first movie was a stand alone they didn't really know if they would make more and really it didn't need sequels. It works on a more primal level. A lot of the story telling is done thru visuals rather than talkin'. Now don't get it twisted it's got its problems too but we're getting off topic. 

Another question. What kind of story should Star Fox have? Should it even have a narrative? I know Miyamoto is against cinematics and gutted the story in Mario Galaxy 2. Well If so what kinds? It can have drama, maturity does not equal swear words and vulgarity. Just look at the Redwall series, all anthropomorphic animals but with a plot that takes itself seriously but still has an air of fun and whimsy about it. Hell Miyamoto said that part of the inspiration for SF was Thunderbirds.(Not exactly GoT but not exactly sanitized either) I feel it can but....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco
7 minutes ago, Ocelotl said:

Lol. Sure there are moments, like I said, but it's not a particularly complex plot. We can agree to disagree. I ain't sayin' it's bad tho. Now it does have an excellent score. I'll agree to that. Let's look to Star Trek, the Borg are a relatively similar menace, the aparoids never take over anyone like they do (a missed opportunity, Pigma is kind of assimilated but Pepper isn't really) but the conflict from those narratives don't come from the fighting but from the internal conflicts. How would we have them in SF? I don't need the Aparoids to be shakespearean but the situations around them. I kinda wish they were a result of Andross' experiments or meddling that could've forced Andrew's forces to be allies and not give the impression that a single, or two, races are evil. Yeah I know about Dash but he almost always ends up as monkey Hitler.

Well on Star Wars; keep in mind that that first movie was a stand alone they didn't really know if they would make more and really it didn't need sequels. It works on a more primal level. A lot of the story telling is done thru visuals rather than talkin'. Now don't get it twisted it's got its problems too but we're getting off topic. 

Another question. What kind of story should Star Fox have? Should it even have a narrative? I know Miyamoto is against cinematics and gutted the story in Mario Galaxy 2. Well If so what kinds? It can have drama, maturity does not equal swear words and vulgarity. Just look at the Redwall series, all anthropomorphic animals but with a plot that takes itself seriously but still has an air of fun and whimsy about it. Hell Miyamoto said that part of the inspiration for SF was Thunderbirds.(Not exactly GoT but not exactly sanitized either) I feel it can but....

Uh, Miyamoto has said that he wants to take an extremely cinematic approach with Star Fox. The Thunderbirds bit influenced the puppets of the first game, and then the talking animation in future games. The biggest inspirations for Star Fox were Argonaut's NESGlider prototype (which the SNES title was based on), and Star Wars. If Miyamoto didn't want cinematics, I really don't think we would have Zelda, Star Fox, or even Donkey Kong as we know it. Storytelling has always been a focus of his. If you're questioning weather of not the series should have a narrative, I think you're eating the crust and missing the pie.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ocelotl    0
Ocelotl
2 hours ago, That Ain't Falco said:

Uh, Miyamoto has said that he wants to take an extremely cinematic approach with Star Fox. The Thunderbirds bit influenced the puppets of the first game, and then the talking animation in future games. The biggest inspirations for Star Fox were Argonaut's NESGlider prototype (which the SNES title was based on), and Star Wars. If Miyamoto didn't want cinematics, I really don't think we would have Zelda, Star Fox, or even Donkey Kong as we know it. Storytelling has always been a focus of his. If you're questioning weather of not the series should have a narrative, I think you're eating the crust and missing the pie.

Yeah I know. That Miyamoto mind is at work again ;) That guy. I kinda want that puppet drama that Miyamoto wanted... sadly the era is gone, why not an animated TV show? Either 2D or 3D? Nintendo really hasn't had much non game media. Weren't there CHoose your own adventure books in the past? I mean heck SOnic Boom still has a a tv show and that game bombed. Miyamoto!!!

Hey man the crust is delicious as well!

Well back to overthinking it. So how should we take Star Fox 1 and 64? Is this a Macross situation where one is a dramatization within the world of Star Fox?

(Also why do fans hate Panther? I don't get it.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco
9 hours ago, Ocelotl said:

Yeah I know. That Miyamoto mind is at work again ;) That guy. I kinda want that puppet drama that Miyamoto wanted... sadly the era is gone, why not an animated TV show? Either 2D or 3D? Nintendo really hasn't had much non game media. Weren't there CHoose your own adventure books in the past? I mean heck SOnic Boom still has a a tv show and that game bombed. Miyamoto!!!

Hey man the crust is delicious as well!

Well back to overthinking it. So how should we take Star Fox 1 and 64? Is this a Macross situation where one is a dramatization within the world of Star Fox?

(Also why do fans hate Panther? I don't get it.)

Just a fyi, Nintendo actually has released a ton of non-game media. You've got stuff like the Hyrule Historia, tons of Nintendo Power comics (most of which were bad), the 1997 SF comic, the 2002 SF manga, a few flash games, a surprising amount of books, a few TLoZ mangas, board games, and maybe one too many 90s game cartoons. (The Super Mario Super Show, the Legend of Zelda cartoon, and the Donkey Kong Country cartoon with the really catchy theme song *HEEEEEYOOOO, look out down below*)

SF64 was a re-imagining of the first game. It was essentially the space epic Miyamoto had wanted, but the SNES couldn't handle. Now, we actually see a similar thing happening with Zero, but this time, Miyamoto has the technology he wanted from the start. If there's one guy that loves the Wii U, it's definitely him.

(I have seen no evidence of fans hating Panther. Most feel either indifferent or positively about him)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ArwingFan    112
ArwingFan

>the 2002 SF manga,

Isn't Farewell Beloved Falco considered canon? Also I haven't seen any hatred for Panther either nor do I hate him myself.

Edited by ArwingFan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco
23 minutes ago, ArwingFan said:

>the 2002 SF manga,

Isn't Farewell Beloved Falco considered canon? Also I haven't seen any hatred for Panther either nor do I hate him myself.

It's complicated. Its end kinda contradicts the very beginning of Adventures, but I consider it to be canon. Mainly becasue Fox gets a sword and the duel that it creates is excellent.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ocelotl    0
Ocelotl
17 hours ago, Ocelotl said:
7 hours ago, That Ain't Falco said:

Just a fyi, Nintendo actually has released a ton of non-game media. You've got stuff like the Hyrule Historia, tons of Nintendo Power comics (most of which were bad), the 1997 SF comic, the 2002 SF manga, a few flash games, a surprising amount of books, a few TLoZ mangas, board games, and maybe one too many 90s game cartoons. (The Super Mario Super Show, the Legend of Zelda cartoon, and the Donkey Kong Country cartoon with the really catchy theme song *HEEEEEYOOOO, look out down below*)

SF64 was a re-imagining of the first game. It was essentially the space epic Miyamoto had wanted, but the SNES couldn't handle. Now, we actually see a similar thing happening with Zero, but this time, Miyamoto has the technology he wanted from the start. If there's one guy that loves the Wii U, it's definitely him.

(I have seen no evidence of fans hating Panther. Most feel either indifferent or positively about him)

 

Man I'd almost forgotten about that weird CGI monstrosity. Donkey Kong what happened!?

Yeah i remember but most of those shows were confined to the 80's and early 90's. They did have that F-Zero anime. I remember it being okay. Kirby was probably their best non-VG effort in that era.

No Star Fox manga eh? Just those short comics? That's a shame.

Hmm maybe I was misreading that. Since Panther gets with Krystal in one of those endings I thought I saw some anti-Panther stuff. Guess I misread it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco
2 minutes ago, Ocelotl said:

Man I'd almost forgotten about that weird CGI monstrosity. Donkey Kong what happened!?

Yeah i remember but most of those shows were confined to the 80's and early 90's. They did have that F-Zero anime. I remember it being okay. Kirby was probably their best non-VG effort in that era.

No Star Fox manga eh? Just those short comics? That's a shame.

Hmm maybe I was misreading that. Since Panther gets with Krystal in one of those endings I thought I saw some anti-Panther stuff. Guess I misread it.

There was a SF manga, it was just short. Only 64 pages. Also, the Nintendo Power comic it got (often referred to as "The Itoh Comic," or "that god awful mess") was over 120 pages and actually contained the majority of the plot of the SNES game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
TheVenetian    9
TheVenetian

Most games involve shooting or otherwise ending the lives of faceless simpletons. If you're going to think about the life and family of the person who you have just killed. Then that's a lot of thinking you have to do, especially if you feel bad about it. So, these games just have to be taken with a pound of apathy.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ocelotl    0
Ocelotl
On 11/7/2015, 10:55:03, TheVenetian said:

Most games involve shooting or otherwise ending the lives of faceless simpletons. If you're going to think about the life and family of the person who you have just killed. Then that's a lot of thinking you have to do, especially if you feel bad about it. So, these games just have to be taken with a pound of apathy.

Indeed. I think this is why it's harder to market Star Fox. WHile yes Metroid does have shooting, for most of the game you're isolated and when you fight they're usually monsters and inhuman looking pirates. A lot of the harshness of SF is softened because everyone is in a vehicle. Well a reason. Of course there's also Nintendo's constant want to innovate. Which is admirable but not necessary all the time. It;s why we haven't gotten a new F-Zero game...

Anyway back to the story of Star Fox. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DZComposer    2,308
DZComposer
On 11/6/2015, 11:40:42, That Ain't Falco said:

Personally, I really don't consider Command canon, not even the 'true' ending.

There is no "True Ending" to SFC. That comes from Dylan Cuthbert, the game's director, himself. Nice thing about that is that It means that most of the game can be considered non-canon due to its "choose your own adventure" storyline.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Scourge    808
Scourge


Thank fuck for that. SFC was horrible in every possible respect, save for the gameplay which itself was only passable at best.

It feels like someone on the story-board team went home one night, set their briefcase down, went to bed, and had all their ideas swapped around for the delusional fanfictions of said dev's 12 year old kid, all written crudely with crayon on construction paper with the occasional chocolate fingerprint stain in one of the corners.

I cannot fathom why anyone didn't immediately notice that the story was an utter pile of execrable trash and suggest: "hey guys, maybe we should actually try to not shoehorn in unnecessary drama and bullshit storyline threads with about a bajillion plotholes, and make a coheasive simple-to-follow story about shooting spaceships in the face"

Command is considered non-canon by the fans, developers, and apparently Nintendo alike if their rebooting of the franchise with Zero is any indication. Given the state of franchise as it is current; this can only be a good thing.

Rot in hell Command, you worthless pile of congealed failure.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Ain't Falco    142
That Ain't Falco

Command is, more or less, the rotten remains of 2 that someone scraped off of the bottom of their boot, licked, and thought tasted okay enough to make a game out of.

Not knocking 2, by the way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ArwingFan    112
ArwingFan

So how do animal products work in the Lylat system? I thought about this when Pigma tells the team to stop treating him like a pork roast in SFZ.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Clearwater    386
Clearwater
11 hours ago, That Ain't Falco said:

Command is, more or less, the rotten remains of 2 that someone scraped off of the bottom of their boot, licked, and thought tasted okay enough to make a game out of.

Not knocking 2, by the way.

While I agree that SF Command was the genuine low for the series story-wise, I don't get why so many people rage over it and instead focus on the better points of the game: for example, the graphics. I did say long ago that for a DS game, the graphics certainly were very good. I also heard a lot about how fun it was to play it online over the Nintendo Wi-Fi Connection.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • TheRadFox987
      By TheRadFox987
      Why didn't Battle Mode make it into Star Fox 2 final release?
    • TheRadFox987
      By TheRadFox987
      My idea for a Star Fox game would be a massive multiplayer online game where people could pilot Arwings and either battle or race each other for galactic win. You could have a customization thing like Guitar Hero where you make not only your own ships but your own characters/wingmates. You could make furries and ships and then launch them into battle! In addition, there would be an adventure mode that would be offline. This mode would be similar to Star Fox Zero but it would be its OWN game and NOT a remake of Star Fox 64. This kind of idea IMO would save the series but only if done properly.
       
      Thoughts?
    • TheRadFox987
      By TheRadFox987
       \ (_,
      / (_)\_( )_\ FOX BECOMES ADDICTED TO CHEESE: EPIC NEW VERSION EDITION
      ) /\/ _ (o)( The Shining Achievement of All FoxKind
      \ \_) (o) /
      \/_/
      A desolate planet of pollution and waste. Venom's Voleech City was ugly as rotting paste. As I say all of this, Fox had to make haste. He was scurrying behind buildings and blasting at bots, bursting their circuits as they screamed out 'bleeps' and 'blots'. Made of tech, they were, they had no blood clots. Fox's boots continued to make more trit-trots, as he fox-trotted his way into the Death Weapon Factory. Robot armies followed him inside, could it be that Fox had nowhere to hide?
      "I need to destroy these weapons so that Andross won't use them against Corneria" Fox thought to himself. He isolated each in a gravitational field, then set a timer on each one, eventually they'd come out well done. Sooner or later, they bursted into flames, sending scrap metal everywhere, killing the robot armies who had no names. Then Fox got an incoming message from Falco, not Slippy. Man oh man, is that bird ever lippy.
      "Andross is here, he's bringing death and fear. Get your ass to Corneria, hurry right now! We can't make cheese, they've slaughtered every last cow! We've even got less freedom here than on Venom, I'm just thanking God that my jacket is Denim" said Falco. Fox jumped in his ship as soon as he could, then set off for Corneria, to restore peace and brotherhood. When he arrived on his homeworld he was not very pleased. The cities were in shambles, even Admiral Z's house of cheese. Cheese had been banned under Emperor Andross's new law. No one could have cheese throughout the land, not cubed nor sliced, not even one strand. Children were crying and wailing in pain, where was Fox when they needed him? No cheese is quite lame! The giant block of cheese atop Admiral Z's had melted down, far down to the ground, trapping Cornerians...wait isn't the earth round?
      "Cheese can't possibly be that frickin' sticky. Something's rotten in Wisconsin, and this ain't no job for Slippy" thought Fox. Fox got an incoming message from Wolf, who was flying overhead. He didn't like Fox, he wanted Fox to be dead.
      "Hey Fox it's the Wolfster, your people are worthless eaters. We added adhesive properties to the cheese, so now they're all stuck. You'll never defeat Andross cuz face it Fox, you suck. Cheese is for losers so kiss your planet goodbye. All you animals must bow before Andross and die" said Wolf. Sick of all the distress and war, Fox couldn't take it, no not anymore. Fox dropped his cell phone, and began losing his mind. He couldn't take what was happening, even so, saving planets was his 9 to 5 grind. But when all seemed lost, Peppy flew by, dispatching himself with a parachute to the ground, sniffing out trouble better than a foxhound. He got out a long stick of measuring tape, and began charting, graphing, and plotting the melted cheese landscape. Finally he knew just what the Star Fox team should do.
      "Ah, dang, I'm gettin' carless. Fox, Gimme a spare Lylation Nova Bomb" ordered Peppy. Fox pulled a Nova Bomb out of his pocket and placed it in Peppy's hands.
      "Ah, that be the one. Now watch and learn Fox mah boy" said Peppy. Peppy began strapping on giant mecha-gloves to prevent his hands from getting stuck, then started lifting up the cheese straight off the earth. That took strength, power, and mirth? He rolled up the cheese against the nova bomb, then hastened to a cannon, firing it at Andross's ships one by one. If they wouldn't let Cornerians have cheese then let them have what they took. In the form of planetary defense prepared by a master cook.
      "DO A CHEESE ROLL!" ordered Peppy.
      "Man, where'd you learn to do that?" asked Fox in amazement.
      "I learned it at the Cooper's Hill Cheese Rolling and Wake. It's an event near Gloucester, England, where they roll cheese down hills. Now if you don't mind, it's time to defeat the emperor's evil shills!" said Peppy, rolling up the nova bomb in all of the melted sticky cheese from the demolition of Admiral Z's restaurant. Fox began rolling up a nova bomb in cheese, and freed all the citizens who had been stuck. Then Fox and Peppy loaded up the cannons, taking out each one of Andross's minions. Eventually appeared Andross himself, pissed off as hell, like a wargod-elf. Fox jumped into his Arwing, and prepared to take him down. He wasn't gonna lose his beloved planet to that Planet of the Apes reject CLOWN!
      "You will die, just like your father" declared Andross.
      "Not over my dead body!" said Fox.
      "You do realize the irony and foolishness of your response, do you not, Fox?" thundered Andross.
      "I realize that you're going down!" said Fox.
      "If I'm going down, then I'm taking you with me" said Andross.
      "NEVER!" yelled Fox.
      "It is foolish to come against me. You know that I control the galaxy!" said Andross.
      "The universe is like waaaay bigger than that" replied Fox. "TASTE CHEESE YOU FREAAAAK!" yelled Fox, firing a cheese laced nova bomb into Andross's mouth. Andross's ship exploded and Andross parachuted himself to the ground, along with his robot buddy and number one confidante and fan...Fantron.
      "I have a splitting headache," said Andross. "Why must I always lose?" he wailed, pounding the earth with his fist.
      "Master, perhaps next time you should attack your own planet, Venom. Then get everyone to think Fox was responsible. Maybe then your people would finally support you and your unquenchable thirst for war" said Fantron.
      "Not a bad idea" said Andross in his evil robotic-like Darth Vader-esque voice. But then Fox cornered Andross, plasma blaster in tow. He looked quite proud, he had put on a good show!
      "Correction Emperor. That's a very BAD idea!" said Fox. "You're going to Corneria War Crimes Prison for at least thirteen years, you won't get any cheese, just cheap Norwegian beers!" Andross looked confused.
      Later that day...
      Fox, Falco, Peppy and Slippy, watching cheese burn in a restaurant founded by a hippie!
      "Yay, Fox!" clapped Falco, Peppy, and Slippy, as a giant block of cheese slowly melted under a candle's flames. They all clinged wine glasses together.
      "LONG LIVE TEAM STAR FOX. AND LONG LIVE THE GLORIOUS GIFT THAT KEEPS ON GIVING...CHEESE!" they all yelled. The three men cheered and shared a group hug, then devoured more cheese and dived into an oversized apple cider jug. Outside the room was the beautiful Krystal, aspy. She had seen enough, Fox just wasn't her guy.
      Note: I took the words "THE END" and made them be out of cheese. Then I rolled them up in an awesomely tasty text sandwich.
      / \ (_, THE END
      ) /\/ _ (o)(
      \ \_) (o) /
      \/_/
       
    • TheRadFox987
      By TheRadFox987
      Krystal Becomes Infatuated with Cheese
      So we all know the story, it had something to do with cheese, and how with cheese Fox was easy to please.
      But there's more to it than that as this new tale shall prove, for this is when Krystal caught on to the groove.
      It started out a day like any other, but Krystal had moved on! Fox was away from her life, yes indeed gone. Mocked for having been part of Star Wolf briefly,
      she took up residence on the delightful Planet Kew. But her true feelings were just like her fur...very blue. So she joined a coven of fox girls just like her, hoping that for her sadness this would be the cure. But it wasn't you see, Fox wasn't gone, deep down in Krystal's heart Fox still lingered on.
      "I'm delighted to attend this meeting as you can see. I'm not the least bit lonely, I feel quite free!" said Krystal.
      "Good," said Fay sitting to the right of Krystal. "Let's do a conciousness raising session, with trees made of nettle!"
      "Sorry to interrupt but she takes cheese to each session. She has some Chedder and Feta right now, I have the most distinct impression" said Fara.
      "No, no, no, I'm not up for that. Why is everyone staring at me and Katt?" asked Krystal.
      "It's the cheeses behind your backs," said Fay with a smirk. "Why not share some with us? Might be a nice perk!"
      "No, I won't" said Katt. "I like cheese too much, cheese I must never lack. My only true boyfriend is Monteray Jack"
      Krystal sighed. She had never been a fan of cheese. But see, Fox was, and his soul was something Krystal just had to appease.
      "This cheese reminds me of someone I loved. Someone I cared for, kissed, and hugged" said Krystal, embarresed. She ran away.
      "She takes that cheese to every meeting here!" said Fay. "AND SHE NEVER EATS IT!" she added.
      KRYSTAL JUMPED IN HER ARWING WITH THE CHEESE IN TOW, SHE WASN'T FEELiNG TOO GOOD, THIS WE ALL KNOW
      "So they don't like me clutching on to cheese, do they? I wasn't about to convince them it was my baby, I need Fox Mccloud back, he's the mashed potato to my gravy" said Krystal. Feeling sad, with dejected eyes, she flew herself into a black hole.
      She got warped to Planet Earth, London UK to be exact. Krystal sounded like she came from there, we'll never know why. Perhaps it's past life stuff, but for now, gotta fly!
      Her arwing crashed and she jumped out with a parachute. She brushed dust off her legs and frantically searched the wreckage for cheese.
      She pulled out some cheese and got down on her knees.
      "Oh, cheese, you'll always be special to me. My one reminder of whom I love, Fox if you're still out there, please show me a dove" said Krystal.
      A dove flew down and stole her cheese. Krystal ran towards a policewoman.
      "You look rather blue," said the policewoman.
      "I am blue, my name is Krystal, yes it's true. A dove flew off into the sky with my cheese, he did not even ask first,
      nor did he say please!" replied Krystal.
      "I can't help you this instant, I think it's been too long a shift. I've never seen a fox person, if you get my drift. But cheese? Yes, it's delicious when spread over fresh mana. Krystal, has anyone told you that you sound just like Princess Diana?" said the cop.
      Krystal broke down in tears and yelled out to the Krazoa to take her away to Fox. So they gave her a test. A taste test of cheeses, conducted by them.
      The Krazoas loved cheese. With cheese they were easy to appease. So they brought her to where Fox was...sitting in a London pub, eating cheese and drinking wine, while helping Falco flick away a bug.
      "Fox," said Krystal tapping Fox on the back. "You know I'm the only one that can understand you, I just have a knack!"
      "Do I know you, blue lady? Oh, Krystal, that's right. It's called a rivalry okay? Let me get back to my rivalries!" said Fox, who then proceeded to chat with Falco.
      "That bird can buzz off, he's bloomin' pissing me off. Now Fox, look at me! We were a team, like Mcnee and Dianna Rigg. Would you forgive me if I handed you a fig?"
      "Figs are old school and I'm just as depressed as you. My nose is stuck to this table like glue!" said Fox.
      "Fox, I have cheese!" said Krystal. Fox looked at the cheese.
      "Get that away!" said Fox violently slapping away the food. Krystal's dress came undone, leaving her in a bikini. All the onlookers looked,
      Krystal, she was damn pretty!
      "Terrific, everyone's staring at me and my rack. Fox won't you please come back?" said Krystal.
      "Can't right now!" said Fox.
      "Oh, please, Fox, let's go right now! Repair to our Arwings, with that food made from a cow" said Krystal.
      "Food made from a cow?" asked Fox, with a twinkle in his eye. "You mean cheese right?"
      "Yes, Fox. Cheese!" said Krystal.
      "To heck with cheese!" said Fox. Krystal started to cry.
      "No, no, hear me out, you must know the reason why!" said Fox. Brushing away a tear, Krystal listened.
      "Krystal I realize I love you more than anything in the universe. You're the greatest gift ever, this I now know, let's rise from the pits where we sunk so low" said Fox. Fox looked into Krystal's eyes, so sweet and sublime. He saw the cheese in her hands, and realized she was one hundred percent divine.
      "I can't believe how foolish I was!" said Fox with a teary eyed grin. He hugged Krystal, and they both shared a kiss. The crowd was confused,
      but to Fox and Krystal, this was bliss.
      "Falco, just admit my boyfriend's a better pilot than you. Go home to your cat, she'll repair your beak like new!" said Krystal.
      Back in the Arwing:
      "You were actually going to change your name to Kursed?" asked Fox.
      "Yes, yes, yes I was. But now we have each other and a cargo hold full of cheese. And our beautiful sets of furs, free of all fleas!" replied Krystal.
      THE END